Welcome to Exit 42 Deli
**Our Story - Exit 42 Deli**
Nestled in Bay Shore, NY, Exit 42 Deli is a vibrant culinary hub celebrating hearty comfort food. As a women-owned and veteran-owned establishment, it prides itself on delivering friendly service and robust flavors. The menu showcases a diverse selection of bagels, sandwiches, and breakfast specials, perfect for any craving. Highlights include the Hungry Man and Mighty Whitey sandwiches, crafted with care and generous portions. Known for its welcoming ambiance and excellent customer feedback, Exit 42 Deli is the go-to spot for a quick meal, takeout, and catering. Experience the warmth and taste that makes every visit memorable.
Exit 42 Deli: Reviews & Ratings
I had a wonderful experience at this bagel shop. wonderful service, the woman was very sweet. would definitely recommend!
Excellent customer service very nicely and friendly.food is very tasty and delicious .
Solid place for your bacon egg and cheese and sausage egg and cheese fix. Haven't tried the other things but always a go to for these!
Stopped in for lunch today. The staff are very friendly and they can make a sandwich in no time! I ordered the italiano and asked for s&p and oil and vinegar to be added...made very well and had lots of deli meats (maybe one more slice of cheese...) and had it on a roll for $5.99! My boyfriend ordered a large penne ala vodka (they don't weigh it they just fill the container for $10.99...and I mean FILL IT) and it was your average pasta considering it's not an Italian restaurant...the sauce could've used a good pinch of salt and the penne was definitely overdone but what can you expect when they make large trays to serve for the day. It did have chicken in it and prosciutto (and he had plenty leftover) so overall a decent dish for on the go lunch. They also have tables to sit and eat at which is a plus as well.
My food was absolutely delicious! My friend recommended this place to me, and I finally came. They gave me a HUGE portion, which I couldnt finish (and I normally do). I was very pleased with my food. They did take a little longer than expected to make my food. It looked like only two people were working in the kitchen. So, next time I'll definitely order ahead of time. They do have a few seating tables that you can have a quick bite at. This place is huge, on the other side it has a deli section. I can't wait to try everything. All the food that I received (in the photo) was only $7.00! Definitely try this place! They do take card as well.
This deli is ginormous! Half of it is a Vape shop and the other half is the deli with the order here/cash out lines. The two are separated by the beverage fridges stocked with everything from milk to beer. Not sure how I feel about that vape section. I don't feel like it's sanitary and I sure as hope they don't actually have people trying flavors in there. The left hand of the store looks like it use to be operational but it looks pretty deserted. It at this size I can see how filling the space as a deli has made itself difficult. I placed my order for BEC on a croissant. He asked me if I wanted SPK and I said absolutely. Nice catch! They don't make iced tea or lemonade during the winter. :c So I ventured the fridges to find an Arizona. No Arizona; I settled for a peach tea Snapple. The sandwich was out in what felt like 3 min. The line to cash out ran even faster and I was out the door on route to work before I knew it. Perfect. I was upset that upon opening my sandwich there was no SPK. Why ask if you forgot faster than I said yes? Anyway. The croissant was bigger than the fillings so I literally had a mouthful of bread for the first few bites. I ate the middles of both halves and threw the rest away like cutting off the crust. Lame! Next time I'll order on a roll and see if they fill it better! Not enough to make me avoid this location because it's conveniently located next to the highway but trust me next time I'll be grabbing a Yoo Hoo to nurture my wounds!
Location
-
270 Spur Dr S, Bay Shore, NY 11706 Hotline: (631) 666-2711
Welcome to Exit 42 Deli, a hidden gem nestled at 270 Spur Dr S, Bay Shore, NY. As you step inside, you’re greeted with the warm ambiance of a welcoming deli that prides itself on its hearty offerings and excellent customer service. This women-owned and veteran-operated establishment is more than just a place to grab a quick bite; it’s a community hub that caters to everyone—from busy workers needing a quick pick-me-up to families looking for some delicious sandwiches to share.
Exit 42 Deli specializes in a variety of mouth-watering sandwiches, all prepared with fresh ingredients. Their signature Hungry Man Sandwich combines eggs, sausage, bacon, and home fries on a hero roll, satisfying even the largest appetites for just $12.99. If you’re in the mood for something lighter, try the Mighty Whitey Sandwich, featuring three egg whites, Swiss cheese, and turkey bacon—a delightful balance of taste and nutrition without sacrificing heartiness.
Beyond their impressive sandwiches, the grill side of the menu boasts delectable options like the Philly Cheese Steak and Bacon Cheddar Burger, with prices ranging from $11.99 to $13.99, ensuring there's something for every palate. The portion sizes are substantial, often leaving customers pleasantly full, which you can especially appreciate from reviews like that of customer Donovan B., who praises the friendly service and delicious food.
The atmosphere at Exit 42 Deli is inviting, with ample seating that invites you to enjoy your meal inside or take it to go. Not only do they offer delivery and takeout, but they are also wheelchair accessible and cater to groups. Their commitment to accessibility and community involvement sets them apart from other delis in the area. The impressive range of beverage options—from classic coffee to refreshing Snapple—complements the food perfectly.
- Location: 270 Spur Dr S, Bay Shore, NY 11706
- Phone: (631) 666-2711
- Ownership: Women-owned, Veteran-owned
- Highlights: Delivery, Takeout, Catering, Wheelchair Accessible, On-Site Parking
As Nina C. mentions in her review, the food portions here are generous, with the added bonus of friendly service, making it a perfect stop for lunch or breakfast. If you're looking for a solid bacon egg and cheese fix or a truly satisfying sandwich, Exit 42 Deli is a must-try destination. With such a broad menu and lovely staff, it's only a matter of time before you find your favorite dish here.
Don’t forget to pair your meal with one of their refreshing drinks or explore their catering offerings for your next gathering. Whether you are dining in or taking out, Exit 42 Deli presents an exceptional deli experience designed to keep you coming back for more.
